It’s been over a year since Google announced that ads would start appearing in AI overviews. Since then, the big Google agencies have been telling businesses to get on board fast, with some suggesting they move half their ad budget across.
Across all the testing 3BY2 has done for clients where the format is available, Mel has hardly seen an ad appear in an AI overview. What she has seen is AI Max, Google’s newest ad type, writing ad copy on its own. For a glazier client, she loaded a landing page about pet doors and it came back promising 24/7 emergency installs, a service the business doesn’t offer.
In Episode 25 of Raising The Bar, Mel Strutt and Monique Jecks get into how ads in AI overviews work, why Google is pushing them so hard and what small businesses should do with their ad budget while the data is still thin.
Before you move any budget across, give this one a listen.
Key Takeaways:
- A year in, there’s little to show: Google says the ads are live and working. In the client accounts where 3BY2 has tested them, Mel is yet to spot one inside an overview, and her research suggests most appear above or below it.
- Showing up in the overview means giving up control: With a traditional search campaign, you choose the keywords, write the ad and pick the landing page. To appear inside an AI overview, Google wants Performance Max or AI Max campaigns, and both lean on broad match.
- Broad match brings the tyre kickers back: On broad match, an ad for specialist European car servicing can show to someone looking up which car brands are European. For businesses that spent years tightening their campaigns to reach buyers ready to act, that’s a step backwards.
- AI Max can write things that aren’t true: AI Max takes a landing page and writes the whole ad for you. For a glazier’s pet door page, it added 24/7 emergency installs. Picture someone who’s been broken into at 1am calling a business that never offered that service.
- The reporting won’t tell you where you showed: Performance Max now qualifies to appear in AI overviews and still lets you write your own ad copy. Its reporting only labels clicks as top ads, though, so you can’t tell whether your ad appeared in the overview or in the blue links.
- Google is racing to monetise AI: ChatGPT has started advertising, and Google wants to win while so many searches still start with it. Broad match sends more clicks and data through Google’s algorithm, and you pay for every one of them.
- Big budgets can afford to experiment: An enterprise brand spending $30,000 to $50,000 a month has room to test. On an $800 budget, five or six wrong clicks at $25 each add up fast.
- The one thing to do now: Set aside a small amount of budget for a Performance Max campaign alongside one of your best-performing exact match search campaigns, and run it for three to four months. Keep your search ads on, and expect pay-per-click results to dip as AI overviews push the blue links further down the page.
Raising The Bar is a fortnightly podcast hosted by Mel Strutt, delivering blunt, experience-backed marketing guidance for Australian business owners. Joined by Monique Jecks, they address what matters, call out the fluff and raise the standard of what marketing must deliver for your bottom line.
Episode Transcript:
Mon: We’re back with another episode of Raising The Bar, and today we’re talking about AI overview ads. So, it’s been over a year now, I think I’m correct, since Google said that ads would show up in AI overviews. So, in that little box that comes up underneath the search bar.
Mel: Yep.
Mon: So once you search, the little AI overview box that comes up. So you’ve got a year of data now. Tell us what’s been happening. What’s been going on there?
Mel: A year of data. Interesting way to phrase it. What we do have is Google saying it’s live, it’s working, jump on the bandwagon. What we do have is the big Google agencies, the ones that make sure they feed the Google machine, saying get on it. Make sure you’re trying it. Divert 50% of your budget to it. You’re literally going to die if you’re not doing this tomorrow. And what we have is [no] evidence that it’s actually doing anything. And I haven’t even really seen an ad show up in all of the testing that we’ve done where it’s been available for our clients. So for me, [unclear] a year on, but I’m starting to see that it’s going to change, and I think it will change quite quickly.
So tonight we’ll talk a lot about AI Max, although other advert types do appear. It’s probably going to get a little bit technical, but it’s worth people listening, because the Google world’s about to change quite a bit in the advertising and pay-per-click space.
Mon: Okay. So if a business owner wants to show up in that space, what are we doing?
Mel: Okay, so if you’re not organically showing up in the AI overview space with search engine optimisation or generative engine optimisation tactics, Google is essentially now saying, “Yep, our adverts are appearing in there.” I did a few things with Gemini early on. What are those ads going to look like? How will they appear? They are more often than not appearing below the overview and above the overview. But if you want to appear in it, it’s a particular type of ad in the Google Ads console.
So you’re used to something like a normal search campaign, right? What we used to be able to do with a normal search campaign is go, cool, I’m going to have a campaign, and it’s going to be for car servicing in Midland. And in that advert, I get to dictate all the key terms that I have. If you actually wanted to show up for local search in Midland and surrounding areas, to be fair, you’d probably do a different type of campaign and do it by a radius, but bear with me on it. So you would dictate the keywords that you want to show up for. You would write the ad copy, so you would write that blue link. You would write the description underneath it. And you would dictate the URL that it was going to go to. That’s essentially setting up the ad. A little bit more complex, but that’s essentially the way you set up the ad.
What you could select is that you could have things called exact match key terms, phrase match key terms and broad match key terms. And for the longest time, broad match has been a dirty word. So in the example of the mechanic in Midland, if you said specialist European car servicing, it meant that on a broad match key term, you could just show for “European car”. Well, that could just be someone searching for a European car, or understanding what a European car is, or which models are European cars. They don’t really have any intent to get their car serviced, and they’re certainly not in Midland, right? So we don’t generally like broad match results. So that’s traditional search.
Mon: So you’ve kind of got those three different definitions.
Mel: Google, a long time ago, had a thing called a dynamic search ad. Not something we used a lot either. I’m not even going to explain what it is, because it’s getting superseded. But then we had Performance Max ads come out, and with Performance Max, you could write your ad copy, but you couldn’t dictate the key terms you showed for. So you couldn’t actually write, “I want to show for European car Midland, and I want to show for Midland European car servicing, and I want to show for European car specialist, and I want them to be phrase match or exact match key terms.” Instead, it dictated what the keyword would be, but also where it would put the ad. So it wouldn’t just be in the blue links. You might show up in a YouTube advert, you might show up in Google Shopping, you might show up in display advertising, right? And for the longest time, it never told you what words you actually converted on. They’ve just more recently started doing that. But you could do negative keywords. You could say, “Oh, I wouldn’t want to rank for that, so never show my ad for that again.” So that was Performance Max.
And now introducing AI Max, the new type of advert that has been showing for a year, but we never talked about because it was pointless. And largely, I still don’t like it at all, but we have to start playing with it, sadly. So what does AI Max do? Well, Google is smarter than all of us, and AI is smarter than all of us, and it never hallucinates. It’s always right. Now, for those of you who aren’t actually watching my face, I’m pulling the piss and I couldn’t be any more sarcastic.
What AI Max does is you give it the landing page that you want the advert to be written about, and it will go and write your entire advert for you. It’ll write the ad copy. It’ll write the description underneath. It will tell you all the terms that you’re going to show for, and they are broad match. So again, we’re not getting that super specific thing. Essentially, Google’s saying if you want to appear in there, it’s got to be broad match. We’ve got to test the algorithm. We’ve got to go back and see when people convert, what do they convert for? Now, you do only pay for a click, so that is true. But you’re suddenly going back to this idea that instead of being hyper-specific and looking for high-intent users looking for what you offer, you’re just showing up in impressions across a lot of different searches, and it’s not specific to you.
And that’s something I have a really broad-based concern with, because Google Ads got really good, and stopped making as much money for Google as it had been, when agencies got really specific and understood their customers. And to be fair, when clients, small businesses, had had enough of, “I’m not actually getting a sale from that, it’s some tyre kicker.” It looks like it’s taking us back there a little bit, and that’s a frustration.
Mon: So possibly more tyre kickers coming back into it, if you turn these things on and you’re not hyper-vigilant with them.
Mel: And again, it’s probably why for about a year we hadn’t really played with it. We knew it sits in the same ad console. We could have turned it on for most people. Not something we’ve been willing to do. And I’ll give you the key reason why. I was playing with an AI Max advert probably about six, maybe eight weeks ago for a glazier, a window repair company we work for. All types of glass, splashbacks, cat doors, those kinds of things. And I loaded in the landing page that I wanted, which was actually for a pet door.
Mon: Mhm.
Mel: And it came up with “24/7 emergency installs” in the advert. He doesn’t do 24/7 emergency installs, but because it’s glass, and glass can be an emergency at particular times, it’s automatically used that in the ad copy. So what an absolute disappointment that’s going to be if someone goes, “Oh, yes, they do 24/7. I’ve been broken into, it’s 1:00 in the morning,” and no one answers the phone and it goes to an answering service, right? So they’re the mistakes it can make. And until that refinement is done, I would have those concerns. But there are circumstances where we are trying them as best we can now.
Mon: So do you want to talk more about those results? If you are in there, what’s that data actually telling you?
Mel: Not a lot. Okay, so where we’re hoping to show up in an AI overview as an advert at the moment would be the clients where we’ve put a specific Performance Max campaign together. We aren’t using AI Max yet, because we’re not going to let it write our adverts for us, if that makes sense. Performance Max is now a qualified ad type to show in the AI overview, but we get to write the ad copy. Boom. So that makes me much happier. Got a bit more control. It’s still fairly broad match, which annoys me a little bit, right? But what the results tell you in Performance Max, again, I think it just says “top ads”. So all it’s telling you is that the click you got was in the top ads for this particular group, the top of the page. But that could have been the blue link. It could have been that you were in the overview. It could have been the blue link below the AI. You don’t actually get to know. So you’re not getting the exact data of where it comes from. And Performance Max has always been ambiguous like that. It has worked in some client cases, but we’ve always kept our traditional exact match and phrase match search campaigns on, because we’ve always been able to really hone them in and get the data, and I guess not make money for Google, but make money for our client.
Mon: So not much transparency there. So why is Google pushing it so hard when there are still so many unknowns?
Mel: I think when we look at AI platforms, right, Google, every AI platform is desperate to monetise in some form, and we know there’s a bubble burst coming in the AI world. We have Claude saying, “We will never advertise. You will pay for what we provide you.” And they also don’t sell their data, so we actually can’t see search terms that come through from Anthropic or Claude. But when we look at the likes of ChatGPT, who are already launching advertising, and we look at the likes of Google, there is a race to monetise. And as a betting woman, there’s a part of me that thinks so much search, so much user experience, still starts as a Google search that the sooner Google monetises how they can manipulate those results with advertising, the sooner they win the race. Because Google Search and pay-per-click is Google’s number one product. It’s unbelievable. They absolutely nailed that.
So why are they pushing this so hard? Well, first of all, broad match opens it all the way back up again. All this ambiguous data and clicks is what we’re paying for. Now, this isn’t terrible for enterprise business. If I’m a Melbourne marketing manager working on a major brand campaign, like a major shoe brand, a Nike or something along those lines, I probably have something in the order of a $30,000 to $50,000 budget a month to spend on ads. And I have a lot of time to play with brand searches, with putting things in, with seeing when I show up, with seeing if I’m going to get mentioned more on broad match, you know, “best running shoes in Perth” or something, right? But when we’re a small business and we’ve got an $800 budget, a $25 wrong click isn’t just $25, and when that happens five or six times across a month, that’s not what we can afford.
So my general view is that when the data’s not good enough and the results are a little bit ambiguous, let big business play and let Google make the rules. Google is pushing this because the more people click and interact, and the more data flows through, the better their algorithm gets at serving the ad. They start understanding when people get a bit uncomfortable that it’s a sponsored link versus not a sponsored link, and they can start to manipulate the user experience, or the GUI, I guess, in terms of how that appears for people. Data’s got to be king at this time. Google always won the ads race over someone like Bing because they had the volume. The person who figures out that experience first, and figures out how to serve ads that don’t piss people off, wins this very, very important race over probably the next three decades.
Mon: So what’s your call then? What should Perth businesses be doing? Should they chase it, have a play, or not?
Mel: I think what we’re doing for our clients, and what Perth businesses should be doing if you’re running adverts, is segregate a little bit of budget. I would say the safe bet is Performance Max at this point in time. Segregate a little bit of budget and pop it into a Performance Max advert alongside one of your higher-performing search campaigns, like a normal exact match campaign, and see how it performs, probably over three to four months. You’re not going to find out if that advert was in an AI overview, right? But what you are able to do is know that perhaps you were in the race, in there a little bit. And as I said, if it’s a small amount of budget, you keep your keyword search ads on. That’s okay, because what we are seeing is a decline in pay-per-click clicks and conversions. And that’s okay, because you would expect that if 48% of searches now show an AI overview, those blue links are now dropping to the bottom, so you’re going to get fewer clicks on them, right? So it’s a great way to play with it for a very minimal budget. But ultimately, what I would say is don’t buy into the “you’ve got to get into it now”, because I think you’ll chase a lot of bad money. Let the big enterprise do that with their big budgets and figure it out, and let the product advance a little bit more.
Really good tools are going to come out. We’re hoping around February there’s a new business [unclear] tool. I can’t remember the exact name of the tool, but I’ll update that next time. We’re hoping it plays a bigger role in understanding the user experience through AI and tracks those URL searches and where the ultimate conversion point happens. At the moment, that’s not live in Australia. Actually, that’s not true. It is live in Australia, but not in the way we need it to be live to actually pilot it properly and really understand the data.
So don’t stress. Put a little bit of budget to the side, if you want to, on Performance Max, or ask your agency to do that for you. And expect that your pay-per-click results are going to go down a little bit, because they’re not at the very top of Google right now.
Mon: Awesome. You’re making this easy for me this week. That all sounds good.
Mel: All right, beauty. Let’s get to work.